Tuesday, February 13, 2007

The Button Collector

Imagine being handed a jar full of words printed on little strips of paper. Imagine being told that your communication could only include those words, although you would be given the freedom to arrange them in any order that you choose.

You could slide "petty" next to "girl." You could make a word train out of "I," "need," "potatoes," and tack on a "please" for the caboose. You might even be able to formulate "I," "want," "to," "hibernate," if "hibernate" was one of the choices. But, if you didn't have "blanket" or a word that meant that, it would be sort of hard to ask for one. And if you didn't have "rickrack," you wouldn't be able to say, "I would like you to make me a shirt hemmed with rickrack."

Overall, the purview of communication would be pretty limited.

Right now, at this time in my life, I feel limited in what I allow myself to communicate. I feel like I've exhausted the options available from the jar, and that the jar was full of discount words, anyway. I want to say "I think that math investigations suck," but I murmur, "Ummmmhmmm" in response to the assistant principal extolling the program's virtues. I want to tell a girlfriend that I am tired of her constant off-color remarks, but I am silent, papercuts in my stomach from the words flickering, trying to get out.

This affects my writing. Instead, of putting all of my suppressed utterances into a story or an essay, I use it as proof that my ideas don't count, that I am not entitled to a voice. It is awful to feel that your own opinions have no value. I will even avoid leaving comments on blogs because I tell myself, Who cares what you think?

So, I am starting, today, to speak little truths. To be careful in the words that I select, and to arrange them in the purest way.

I might start out with "No, thank you" or "I disagree" but I will not limit myself to the words in the little jar that I have been using, over and over again, during the past year.

I want to say: I'm not comfortable with what you're saying. That's rude. It's not my responsibility. That's hypocritical. What's your point in telling me that I look tired? Here's my idea. That's ignorant. Who cares? I agree. I like that. This is what I want. I hate that. That's not right. Oh, you're amazing. Let's go. I'd rather eat seafood. I want a second helping. I'll pass on the sweet potato-pear bisque. Your poetry changes me. I will not tolerate a bully.

I'm tired of shortchanging my accomplishments because someone else is depressed about their own. I'm tired of pretending that my husband isn't exemplary, just because a friend's marriage isn't where she wants it to be. I'm tired of believing that I am not entitled to expectations/hopes/desires because I have a decent life.

I want to take risks with the use of language again, and I'm going to.

Time to recycle the word jar. Or, to start collecting buttons.

22 Comments:

Blogger claireylove said...

...or fashioning some new buttons of your own?

Great new intention Cate ~ and I always care what you have to say when you blog and when you comment :-)

2/13/2007 9:58 AM  
Blogger cherry girl said...

Good for you for breaking that glass jar! Your opinions do count and I love it when you leave comments!! I agree that pushing down the words you want to express slices up your insides - not healthy! Be true to yourself, cos I think your fab (and hey that's just through blogging so you must be at least 3 times as great in 'real' life!)

2/13/2007 10:00 AM  
Blogger Cate said...

BB, Arrrghhh--thank you so much for that comment--your blog is one of the hardest to leave comments on because your words are so beautiful that they make anything I write in response seem trite and ugly in comparison. I generally revert to "I love this," which is true, but does not do the post/poem justice! xo

CG, oh, I think that you're fab, too--anyone who does morning pages and likes Julia Cameron and chocolate is a soul sister! Thank you for those kind words! xo

2/13/2007 10:07 AM  
Blogger Lou said...

You know I always love your words. They are always so beautiful.

BTW, you can always leave a comment on my blog.

Love ya!

2/13/2007 11:25 AM  
Blogger Kamsin said...

Hi, I'm quite new around your blog but I just wanted to say that I really love your image of a glass jar full of words. I don't mean because it's good that you feel limited in the words you can use to express yourself, but because it is a very very good way to express what you are struggling with.

When I was younger I never used to speak very much at all if I could at all help it, thinking about it now I'm not even sure what I was afraid of, but I guess like you I didn't think anyone was interested in what I had to say, or I might say the worng thing. But I guess I learnt the fear is worse than the reality, that it isn't true. You have a valuable voice which needs to be heard. Good luck banishing that glass jar!

2/13/2007 11:33 AM  
Blogger LDahl said...

You could always have some wicked-good-fun with those words. Like when your friend says something off color, tell her what she has just said reminds you of something an ex-girlfriend of yours once said....... then don't say anything more and wait for her to ask what it was ... then reply, oh I can't repeat it, I blanked it from my mind it was so *insert fun word of your choice*(hideous,repulsive, offensive) Then walk away shaking your head.
For even more fun, tell Hubby in advance what you are planning to do and both of you make a list of three possible responses your friend might make, the one closest to the actual response, takes the other out to a fancy dinner. You'll be happily waiting for the next off color remark instead of dreading it!
(If she doesn't get it the first time, the next time she makes a remark that makes you uncomfortable, throw your hands up in the air and say you've just blanked "that" from your mind!)
Don't break your jar, break the mold, have fun and let the words out to play:)))
Don't be afraid Cate, you are so special, don't hide your light under a basket.
"Who cares what you think?" I do, I care very much. And I ain't chopped liver girl!(more like chopped gall bladder:)

2/13/2007 1:53 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hmmmm, I've had to come back and read this multiple times (mainly because kids were interupting)and also because it moved me deeply.

Cate sweetheart you are amazing. How you managed to put this down rocked my world. You echo so perfectly what so many women, myself included, feel. We are always suppose to be polite, and the "good girl"...but fuck that shit, it is 2007! I love your new jar of words hon and I want to brainstorm some more words with you.

I love you and your thoughts.
Hugs,
a.

2/13/2007 7:27 PM  
Blogger Deirdre said...

The only thought making its' way through my brain right now is that I'm in awe of your writing and now I find out you're not even using all your words. Holy smokes, honey! I need to go batten down the hatches.

I find myself stepping away from truth too often as well, letting things slide because I don't want to make anyone uncomfortable and brushing aside my own discomfort for the same reason. Maybe this is the year we learn to speak up.

2/13/2007 11:51 PM  
Blogger Deb R said...

Good for you, Cate!! I want to see you scribble a bunch of new and powerful words - hundreds of them! - and put them in that jar to pull out any time you want them. You're entitled to every single word you want.

And I hope you never hesitate to leave a comment on my blog. EVER.

2/14/2007 12:01 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Here's to speaking your words of truth and you can channel me and my BIG mouth that has no problem saying what I think/feel/need. My husband is convinced this is why I sleep so well, I leave nothing on the table.

You are entitled dear Cate, so entitled.

2/14/2007 8:37 AM  
Blogger runliarun said...

It's called self-assertion, but you put it much more beautifully.

2/14/2007 5:12 PM  
Blogger Shannon Hopkins said...

Well now, I'm sitting here thinking whatever I say will just sound dull or boring or monotonous because everyone else has already said it, which is what usually happens when I want to comment, so I say nothing instead. And you captured it so well, as everyone above has said. A lovely post.

2/14/2007 6:52 PM  
Blogger Amber said...

"papercuts in my stomach from the words flickering, trying to get out."-- This line is brilliant!

You have to find your voice, because you have just a mind for words. Stop thinking that you should stay quiet! Raise your voice, Cate! Use it. Use what you have. Other people might not be able to say what you could, the way you can...and maybe they are waiting for someone to say it.

:)

2/14/2007 7:39 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sounds like a good choice, to lay out what you want to say, to rearrange the options you have.

Imagine it, think it, believe it, act it, say it, be it.

2/16/2007 5:59 PM  
Blogger cloud said...

I know I've said this before but I love your writing style!

Go on, say what you feel like saying. Dont be afraid that it deviates from the 'model answer' response. (:

I could do with a dose of that too.

2/16/2007 8:20 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wow...I don't have a thing to say except WOW. As usual, you are in my head. Just astounding writing.

2/17/2007 12:59 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I feel like I consistantly say the same things to you over and over but each little nibble of yourself that you share with us just eats away at my soul and I feel changed after having read it. I feel alongside you in your fight and struggle.

You are not alone.

2/17/2007 11:00 AM  
Blogger Becca said...

Wow, were you in my head with this post! These words especially just sent shivers down my spine - "but I am silent, papercuts in my stomach from the words flickering, trying to get out" - because you so perfectly described a very familiar feeling.

You have a marvelous way with words, as evidenced by this very strong, well written post. I would love to hear/read more of them :)

2/17/2007 1:57 PM  
Blogger Leah said...

what a great post! seems to me you have many more words to use than what's in that jar. perhaps it's time to fill that jar with water, let those overused words bleed out and jumble, so that what you're left with is a jar full of letters mixed up and ready for you to go fishing in.

2/17/2007 7:14 PM  
Blogger Cate said...

Thank you ALL for your encouraging words. It "warms me heart" to realize that I am not alone--that so many of you have struggled (or struggle) with the same feelings, and I am greatly moved by those of you who have CONQUERED that tendency to quiet one's own voice (and can, consequently, fill your glass jars with things other than words!).

Your commments (everysingleoneofthem) energize me in ways that you will never realize. I think of your support when I am drifting off to sleep, when I am counting change at Target, when I am stirring homemade soup . . .

Thank you. xo

2/18/2007 1:33 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Whohoo! I like this strong post "time to recycle the word jar."

2/19/2007 3:02 AM  
Blogger GoGo said...

Recyle those words and just let it go. I see what your capable of when your voice is in full throtle, which was totally spelled wrong.

Its funny, we never want to hurt people around us, so we hurt ourselves with silence, we change ourselves instead of the relationships. There is a balance between rudeness and honesty...its there, find it, and your words will soar with you.

Besides, I'm excited to see what comes out of that jar of yours!

2/23/2007 10:45 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home