Monday, January 30, 2006

Peter Menzel

It is foggy here, in my mind: a glasses, homemade socks, and book wearing kind of day. I'm taking Mac to the dentist, and I will tuck several books into my purse; the book queue lengthens daily, like a line at the grocery store before a clipper.

My "outfit" of choice for home consists of cocoa striped socks and Peter Menzel's "Material World," a book which is too big for reception area perusing. I first learned about it while visiting Jill's Notebook about a month ago.

Through stunning photography and words, Menzel tells a thousand stories. He is a relayer of cultural details, an enlightener. To create this book, Menzel traveled the world, taking pictures of families from numerous countries, in front of their house or shelter, surrounded by all of their possessions. Menzel's pictures repeatedly stamp an impression of the various societal conditions, affluence, and values that exist across the Earth, from walls repaired with dung in Ethiopia to a rancher in Texas, brimming with duplicate items and knick knacks. What can I say as I look around my own house, cluttered with books and electronics and plastic toys and shiny appliances. That I am lucky? It sounds so trite. That my future goals involve the purchase of a Calphalon non-stick pan, while other people are praying for an education? I hang my head.

The first step is acknowledgement.

Mac is enamored with this book. Every night, we talk about a region and the family that lives there. Last night, he and his dad discussed a German family. After Mac went to bed, I read about Mongolia.

I was surprised that only one family from the United States was depicted. The American family in the book is middle class, a representative, I suppose, of the "norm." I would've respected attention given to poorer American people, too--a homeless family, a single parent family--that is an American reality, too. The wealthier would have had a place, also--McMansions and luxury cars, walk-in closets stuffed with clothes, like bolts of material wedged alongside of each other at a fabric shop.

As for me, there is the gift of having free time to explore this book, a house to complain about and remodel. Lamenting a slow internet connection or the fact that the town rarely puts on a decent art show.

Pheeehh. These are not the things that matter.

Some people don't worry about "balance" in their lives because they have more pressing concerns: enough work, enough food, sickness, access to medicine, access to education. Basics. Not anything close to Maslow's vision of self actualization because everyday is a struggle to solidify the bottom levels of the pyramid: the safety, the shelter and the food. But there are similarities between global families, too: a love and a concern for our children, a desire for good health, freedom at some level (however one might choose to define it).

This book has made me reexamine the things that I take for granted, not that my arm chair reflection helps anyone who is in a less fortunate situation. I have redefined my heroes as the people who take time out of their lives to volunteer, here or abroad.

This book is a good one. I'm glad that my library carried it, although a paperback version is available through Amazon. I'm also looking forward to reading another of Menzel's books, "Hungry Planet: What the World Eats," soon.

11 Comments:

Blogger Out Of Jersey said...

I'll have to check it out, I love photography. My father was a photographer back in the day and since then I've enjoyed that sort of thing.

As for the middle class family, remember a time when white middle class men were considered responisble for all the ills of society?

2/01/2006 9:38 AM  
Blogger Dana said...

Here is what separates you from the majority of people- You are thoughtful and insightful. Most people would look through that book and say, "Hmm, how interesting." But you see the depth and it touches you in your soul. Your eyes are open and you are aware. And you are grateful for what you have. I think this is touching in itself. As well as rare!

xoxo

2/01/2006 3:11 PM  
Blogger The Egel Nest said...

Hmm..how interesting...

just kidding! :)

Insightful is an understatement! This was educational!

I will definietly check out your suggestion :)

Bradley
The Egel Nest

2/01/2006 5:30 PM  
Blogger Michelle said...

The Menzel book sounds really interesting and refreshing. I like what you said about there only being one American family depicted. Why should there America get more than one family? Although I see your point about poor Americans as well as rich being just as representative as middle class but you could say the same of almost every county. I love anthropological looks at cultures. I think I might have to put this book or "Hungry Planet: What the Word Eats" on my birthday wish list.

2/02/2006 12:32 AM  
Blogger Michelle said...

The Menzel book sounds really interesting and refreshing. I like what you said about there only being one American family depicted. Why should there America get more than one family? Although I see your point about poor Americans as well as rich being just as representative as middle class but you could say the same of almost every county. I love anthropological looks at cultures. I think I might have to put this book or "Hungry Planet: What the Word Eats" on my birthday wish list.

2/02/2006 12:32 AM  
Blogger buck said...

put me in line along with the rest for checking this book out. really appreciate your perspective on it.

2/02/2006 12:45 AM  
Blogger Cate said...

CR,
It was nice hearing your personal connection to photography--do you have many of your father's pictures? If so, what a gift.

Baylor,
You are so kind to me! It was this book, though--I was stunned by my reaction to it. I thought that it was just going to be interesting, but it was incredibly informative, too--I walked away feeling so ignorant, but WANTING to learn more. Thank you so much for your comment!

2/02/2006 8:15 AM  
Blogger Cate said...

Bradley,
Yes, yes, I cannot say enough positive things about this man's work. Just a gifted, generous human! If you get a chance to read it, let me know what you think.

Nance,
Thank YOU for your link to Alec Soth. It was so great, looking at his work.

Michelle,
Ah, yes. Lou and I had the same discussion yesterday--about how Menzel would have had to include multiple families for every country, to show all of the different socioeconomic classes in each one, if he included more than representative for the US. And Lou also mentioned to me--how do we know what's the norm--Menzel never states that he's including "typical" representatives of anyplace. He's just taking an objective look at various families, documenting what they have, and including background info. about the region. You should see it, Michelle-Menzel's got population doubling rates, fertility rates, literacy rates, etc. It's SO informative (I keep using that word--need to get on thesaurus.com to find another to mix it up a bit!). Thanks for the comment.

2/02/2006 8:44 AM  
Blogger Out Of Jersey said...

Cate, I hate to admit that I do not, except for the personal family photos. Every so often I'll be over someones house we know and see a little foto my dad took. Though there is one of myself when I was a baby where I had a yield patch sown on the butt of a pair of osh kosh's. He sold several copies of that picture.

2/02/2006 9:43 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This sounds like a "must have" book. Yes.. we are blessed with so much and often take for granted all that we have.

2/02/2006 3:06 PM  
Blogger Laini Taylor said...

Coming late to this post so I hope you see it, but it was weird to see this because just yesterday I was thinking of this wonderful book! I had the fun experience of introducing Peter Menzel at the bookstore where I used to work in California, when this book came out. He came to do a slide show and talk and I was so blown away by it. It has lodged in my mind ever since. Great concept. I always remember, too, how many of those families had televisions, and how even if they didn't get reception in their own language the TVs were always going. How TV broadcasts must change people's perception of their own lives. Brings to mind another book I introduced at that bookstore, about Albania -- the author contended that the day Albania, very sheltered and isolated, received its first broadcasts from neighborning countries, so many people tried to cross the Adriatic to Italy THAT DAY that boats were sinking in the harbors under their weight! The power of media to give context to our lives!

2/08/2006 1:50 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home